Top Spring 2014 Anime: Final Ratings

It’s kind of crazy to think that I was still in England when this season started. Where I am now, both as an anime watcher and and blogger, seems quite far away from where I was then. It was a good season, though—one that saw my entry into Reddit, the start up of an ambitious Best Girl tournament on the Crunchyroll forums and my first steps into the aniblogger world. But about that anime…. I picked up a lot more shows than I wanted to actually watch, discovered a new show that I really like (Love Live!), was let down by numerous shows, dropped way more shows than I usually do, was charmed by Chaika and wowed by my first Masaaski Yuasa show. So, yeah. Spring 2014 wasn’t a bad season for me. I won’t say some shows didn’t become tedious at times, but overall it was a pretty good season, with Week 8 (headlined by Hunter x Hunter, of course) standing head and shoulders above all the rest. Here’s how things shook out.

Nisekoi

1. Ping Pong the Animation (9/10)

As the difference in ratings demonstrates, Ping Pong was the best anime of Spring 2014 by a long shot, short pips. With as many anime that struggle to tell a complete story in 13, or even 26 episodes, Ping Pong just goes to show that you can tell a story of any length well if you know what you’re doing. As top shows do, Ping Pong is taking home a large swath of the awards for the season, none of which are more true than Kong Wenge bringing in the Best Male Character award. I mean, he sang karaoke. (Full review of Ping Pong)

Awards: Best of Spring 2014, Best Story, Best Drama, Best Male Character—Kong Wenge (Honorable Mentions: Best OP, Best ED, Best Male Character—Peco, Best Animation)

2. One Week Friends (7/10)

Up through episode 8 One Week Friends looked like it was going to pull out an 8/10, but the final arc just wasn’t able to conjure the emotional investment of episodes 4 or 8. That’s okay, though. One Week Friends turned out to be a heart-warming show about friendship and doing the hard work necessary to have friends. It shone in the little moments, in the small looks and phrases of its characters. On the awards side, the OP animation was simply gorgeous, and the song was probably the most perfect match for the tone of the show of any opening theme. (Episode 8 Write-Up, Episode 9 Write-Up)

Awards: Best OP, Best Slice-of-Life (Honorable Mentions: Best Romance, Best of Spring 2014)

One Week Friends

3. Hitsugi no Chaika (7/10)

Ah, Chaika. How I love thee! Chaika was something of a pocket show, a comfort food show. I pretty much knew I was going to like it from the start, and then was pleasantly surprised to find out just how much I ended up liking it. The run of episode 5-7, which were totally dorky and weird, I loved. Throw in the actual best action sequences of the entire seasons in a fun fantasy setting—and how could I forget Chaika’s facial expressions?—and you’ve got my personal favorite show of the season. (Chaika Gif Collection)

Awards: Personal Favorite of Spring 2014, Best Action, Best Adventure, Best Fantasy (Honorable Mention: Best Male Character—Toru)

3A. Tonari no Seki-kun (7/10)

Tonari no Seki-kun is 3A because 1) it ended in the middle of the season, and 2) I forgot about it when I first typed out the rankings list and I didn’t want to re-number every show. But, anyways. Tonari no Seki-kun is an incredible show. It’s comedic genius in 7 minutes, and the fact that it managed to be hilarious for 21 broadcast weeks in a row without growing stale speaks to the quality of the formula and the creativity behind each and every scenario. Throw in what was one of the best Kana Hanazawa performances she’s ever done, and you’ve got yourself a winner.

Awards: Best Comedy, Best Short Series (Honorable Mention: Best Female Character—Rumi Yokoi)

Tonari no Seki-kun

4. selector infected WIXOSS (7/10)

Other than Ping Pong, no other show did more with less this season that WIXOSS. After a solid first episode and then an abysmal run of episodes at the beginning of the show, WIXOSS stabilized and then just got better and better as the season wore on. As evidenced by the number of episodic posts I did on it, WIXOSS left me with a lot to think about. The second season has a lot of work to do in tying up loose narrative and thematic strands, but I think Mari Okada can do it. Then again, Nagi no Asukara took a nose dive in its second cour…I’m just hoping the kinks got worked out early on in WIXOSS, for the betterment of the whole show. (Episode 1 Write-Up, Episode 7 Write-Up, Episode 10 Write-Up, Episode 11 Write-Up, Episode 12 Write-Up)

Awards: (Honorable Mentions: Best Story, Best Drama, Best of Spring 2014)

5. Haikyuu!! (7/10)

In sheer exuberance, no show this season matched Haikyuu!! And no show matched the production values, either. Haikyuu!! looks great, and there are numerous truly spectacular animation sequences that dot the show. It’s nothing new or innovative on the story front, but it’s an enjoyable, energetic watch each and every week. It doesn’t steer too far into angst, and it works to keep itself rooted in reality. It’s just some kids having fun playing volleyball, and we get to watch them. And that’s not supposed to sound sad.

Awards: Best Animation

Haikyuu!!

Hi. We play volleyball. It is a chill sport.

6. Love Live! 2 (6/10)

A late pick-up for me, and one that I wasn’t sure I’d like, Love Live! 2 turned out to be a new favorite of mine. It’s unrestrained positivity almost the whole way through, and even if my suspension of disbelief was shattered watching the musically superior A-RISE (c’mon, “Shocking Party” was the best song in the entire season) be defeated and an entire school show up to shovel the entire city, I found Love Live! 2 a refreshing watch because of that positivity. Love Live! 2 absolutely believes in the goodness of humanity, and we surely can use more of that in the world. (First Impressions of Love Live! 2)

Awards: Best ED (Honorable Mention: Best Slice-of-Life) 

Love Live! 2

7. The World is Still Beautiful (6/10)

An amazing lead couple in one of the most genuine and authentic displays of romance to have ever graced my laptop screen is held back a bit by a weak middle, but the show ended strong. Sometimes, you just have to take the best you can get and be happy with it and when shows like The World is Still Beautiful are at their best in character relationships, that’s always going to be a reason to watch. Nike was a fantastic character throughout andRena Maeda was spectacular as her VA—get this girl more roles! (Full Review of The World is Still Beautiful)

Awards: Best Romance (Honorable Mentions: Best Fantasy, Best Female Character—Nike Remercier)

7A. Nisekoi (6/10)

Solidly entertaining, very pretty. The harem itself was okay, but the supporting cast behind the main duo (yes, I mean Raku and Chitoge—Onodera is a big pile of boring) was quality. I liked Nisekoi and I’ll watch more when it inevitably comes out, but I’m not pretending this was anything more than pandering entertainment. It’s nice to be pandered to, sometimes. (Full Review of Nisekoi)

Awards: Best Harem (Honorable Mention: Best Animation, Best Romance, Best Comedy)

Nisekoi

Best girl gotta best girl.

8. Mekaku City Actors (6/10)

What can I say about this show that I haven’t already? Wasted potential in the extreme, SHAFT liking being SHAFT a bit too much. And Kana Asumi rocking it out as the best character in the entire anime. Ene’s episodes were far and away the best part of the show; not great enough to merit watching the whole show for them—but the whole experience of Mekaku City Actors is so disjointed that anyone could probably watch them and have the same positive experience of them that I did. (Full Review of Mekaku City Actors)

Awards: Best Female Character—Takane “Ene” Enemoto

9. Is the Order a Rabbit? (5/10)

Pleasant, endearing, easily-digestible and ultimately somewhat forgettable. Unlike comparable shows like Non Non Biyori and Kiniro MosaicIs the Order a Rabbit? was neither funny enough or existentially relaxing enough to merit a great deal of affection from me, but I’ll watch the next show that comes out like this. And the one after that. Because, even though I don’t like coffee that much, I can still appreciate the smell.

Awards: (Honorable Mention: Best Slice-of-Life)

Is the Order a Rabbit?

We’ve all been there, Rize…

10. No Game No Life (5/10)

“I’m a Steph,” while it has reached meme level in the wider anime culture, just isn’t a great of a line as, “Dammit, Marco!” No Game No Life was fun, I’ll admit. But between abusing Steph right and left (people find this crap funny?) and the in-your-face fanservice, No Game No Life just overwhelmed a lot of my tolerances. It may sound hypocritical coming from a blogger who mostly liked Nisekoi, but just because I like being pandered to sometimes doesn’t mean I can’t tell when a show is trying to manipulate me. And I tend to get stubborn when I feel I’m being toyed with.

Awards: (Honorable Mention: Best Adventure)

11. Black Bullet (5/10)

Black Bullet‘s biggest problem was that I realized early on that I couldn’t take the show seriously, and yet it still kept insisting that I should take it seriously. The cute moments were great and some of the dramatic moments were great (mostly the Enju-centric ones). And then sometimes the anime descended to Mahouka like levels of just…what? Probably the only thing that is keeping Black Bullet in 5/10 territory, and just barely, is that I found Enju somewhat compelling and enjoyed the mostly refreshing relationship between her and Rentaro. Now if we could stop writing ten-year-olds that try to work their sexuality on high schoolers…

Black Bullet

I can’t be the only person who was thinking about Shu Ouma here, right?

12. Fairy Tail (4/10)

Not as fun, not as well-produced as the first iteration of the franchise. First time I’ve ever seen a show where the obvious lack of production values truly damaged my experience. Add in tepid and listless pacing and bad direction and you’ve got yourself a show that is only a shadow of its former self. It’s unfortunate I’m already 175 episodes emotionally invested and always expecting the “next episode will be better!” Now, I’m probably just going to put up with whatever the show throws my way hoping against hope that it will clamber out of the muck it’s in.

13. The Irregular at Magic High School (3/10)

Boring, politically controversial, far too uptight for its own good. I did get a lot of good laughs out of the bad writing in the first cour, but you can only laugh at bad things for so long before you start to feel sad. Mahouka makes me feel sad, so I’m dropping it, onii-sama.

Awards: (Honorable Mention: Best Comedy)

The Irregular at Magic High School

Dropped:

Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou (1 ep), Soul Eater NOT! (9 eps), Brynhildr in the Darkness (3 eps), If Her Flag Breaks (3 eps), Kamigami no Asobi (1 ep)

3 thoughts on “Top Spring 2014 Anime: Final Ratings

  1. Kind of late to this, but you should give Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou another shot! I wasn’t sold on its first episode either, but by episode 3 and on the show really shines.

    Like

  2. I would second that recommendation for Bokura wa Minna Kawaisou… You gave up before it got good. Though I must admit, the first ep doesn’t really give a proper taste of the rest of the series.

    One Week, yeah it was a few episodes too long, but it’s still one of my favorites. Rewatched the first arc just the other week.

    Love Live 2. I starting watching the first season about halfway through this season, ended up marathoning it and then 2 so I could watch the last of 2 in real time. Yeah, Shocking Party was the best song of both seasons. OTOH next to the first version of Start:Dash!!, Door of Dreams is my favorite μ’s tune. Two outstanding songs in one ep.

    I found this a while back – someone made a mashup of Shocking Party that stretches it to a full length song. It’s pretty good.

    Irregular, I watched both cour and found it very uneven. Some very good bits (the magic tournament in the second cour had some very well thought out games) but quite a bit of drek too.

    Mangaka-san to Assistant-san to Totally funny even if it was the same four jokes retold over and over again.

    Kamigami no Asobi. dropped just like you – at one ep.

    And there you have it… My second full season watching current anime, a stunning six shows. (The same total as Winter 2014.) In part I think because I hadn’t managed to discover ANN yet, or figured out how the whole affair worked so finding things was hit-or-miss. By the next season I had done both, and the number I was watching (at least at the start of the season) went into double digits and has never dipped below.

    Watched Tonari no Seki-kun sometime later, and laughed our butts off. We still re-watch select episodes now and again. (The ones featuring shogi ought to be a real hoot after watching March comes in like a lion.)

    And dangit, I’ve written more coherent thoughts and words in a half hour here than on the entry I’ve been struggling with all day for my own blog. That’s the biggest challenge I face – I really do my best work when I have someone else to bounce off of.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s